New videos DAILY:
Join Big Think Edge for exclusive video lessons from top thinkers and doers:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
You can be committed to science, but as soon as you’re committed to a hypothesis, you’ve walked off the trail of objective truth, says Richard Dawkins. For him, that is the mission of science and the purpose of the scientific method: these truths exist—they are the foundations of innovations like vaccinations, antibiotics, and space travel, because they are built on something solid: evidence. Einstein is known for highly valuing the role of imagination in science, and Dawkins agrees: imagination and intuition are the springboards scientific progress depends on—but when evidence refutes a hypothesis or a feeling, that’s the end of the line. Dogged persistence doesn’t get you any closer to the truth, says Dawkins, only critical thinking can do that. Richard Dawkins’ latest book is Science In The Soul: Selected Writings of a Passionate Rationalist.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RICHARD DAWKINS
Richard Dawkins is an evolutionary biologist and the former Charles Simonyi Professor of the Public Understanding of Science at Oxford University. He is the author of several of modern science’s essential texts, including The Selfish Gene (1976) and The God Delusion (2006). Born in Nairobi, Kenya, Dawkins eventually graduated with a degree in zoology from Balliol College, Oxford, and then earned a masters degree and the doctorate from Oxford University. He has recently left his teaching duties to write and manage his foundation, The Richard Dawkins Foundation for Reason and Science, full-time.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TRANSCRIPT:
Richard Dawkins: The first chapter of ’Science in the Soul’ is called ’The Values of Science and the Science of Values’. And it does, of course, give prominence to objective truth. There is a kind of whispering campaign—more than a whispering campaign, sometimes a yelling campaign—against the value of objective truth. Science, I think, is committed to objective truth; we’re committed to the view that truth is independent of the cultural background of the scientist, for example. So as I said in the book, an experiment done in a lab in New York can be replicated in a lab in New Delhi, and if it’s all done correctly in the same way they’ll get the same result. Science’s belief in objective truth works. Engineering technology based upon the science of objective through achieves results: it manages to build planes that get off the ground, it manages to send people to the moon and explore Mars with robots, and land robotic vehicles on comets. Science works. Science produces antibiotics, it produces vaccines that work. So anybody who chooses to say, “Oh, there’s no such thing as objective truth, it’s all subjective, it’s all socially constructed,” tell that to a doctor, tell that to a space scientist.
Manifestly, science works and the view that “there is no such thing as objective truth” doesn’t. Science proceeds, I believe, in the sort of Popperian view that science proceeds by intuitive leaps of the imagination, building an idea of what might be true and then testing it by experiment, by observation, in the second phase. It’s a kind of Darwinian selection of mutation, which is provided by the imagination.
So intuition is very important, but it is important that scientists should not be so wedded to their intuition that they omit the very important testing phase, and if their hypothesis is disproved they should regard that as a reason to reject the hypothesis or modify it, not a reason to just carry on doggedly sticking to the hypothesis because they are intuitively committed to it.
The phrase ’critical thinking’ is quite a cliché but it is immensely important. And so I think that I really could sum it up by saying what we need is critical thinking; we need to respect evidence, we need to respect the fact that the only reason to believe anything about the real world is evidence. The evidence must be assessed critically, preferably statistically and logically. You cannot derive truths about the real world by intuition alone, by feelings alone, by what feels good.
People who say things like, “All opinions are equally valid,” or, “Well, it’s true for me, it may not be true for you.” Never tolerate that kind of thing. The only reason to believe anything is true is that there’s evidence, and everybody should either look at the evidence for themselves or they should trust that the person they’re talking to has looked at the evidence in a scientific, logical, rational,...
For the full transcript, check out
1 view
85
32
5 months ago 00:04:13 1
The Rolling Stones - She’s A Rainbow (Official Lyric Video)
5 months ago 01:19:01 1
194 WUP Walter Veith & Martin Smith - Mark of The Beast, Hand Or Forehead, How Close Are We?
6 months ago 01:19:01 1
194. Das Malzeichen des Tieres, wie nahe sind wir? # Walter Veith, Martin Smith # What’s up Prof?
6 months ago 00:27:19 1
What Game Theory Reveals About Life, The Universe, and Everything
6 months ago 00:17:21 1
How ONE Parable of Jesus HUMBLED Richard Dawkins
6 months ago 00:02:48 1
The Rolling Stones - As Tears Go By (Official Lyric Video)
6 months ago 00:04:48 1
The Rolling Stones - 2000 Light Years From Home (Official Lyric Video)
6 months ago 03:16:30 1
Islamist Mohammed Hijab Says Jews Should Die | David Wood & Apostate Prophet LIVE
6 months ago 00:00:57 1
Muslim Responds To Richard Dawkins: “Christianity Is A Decent Religion.“ | Adnan Rashid
6 months ago 00:06:23 1
The Rolling Stones - Sympathy For The Devil (Official Lyric Video)
6 months ago 00:40:17 1
“Arrest me!“ JK Rowling v Hamza Yousaf. Could Scotland’s Hate Speech Law Bring Down the Government?
6 months ago 00:52:06 1
Richard Dawkins Begs Christianity to Come Back | Ep 979
6 months ago 00:35:17 1
Avocado TV schaut nach Berlin - NPCs überall! - Mein Part vom Osterspecial 2024 - Vollversion
6 months ago 00:04:13 1
Richard Dawkins DEFENDS Cultural Christianity
6 months ago 00:12:54 1
You Won’t BELIEVE What ATHEIST Richard Dawkins Just Said About CHRISTIANITY!!!
6 months ago 00:35:23 1
Richard Dawkins Calmly Talks About “Talking to the Dead“
6 months ago 00:50:59 1
4,6 Bilhões de anos em 50 minutos: A história da evolução!
6 months ago 01:39:10 1
The Darien Gap & Postmodernism | Bret Weinstein | EP 434
6 months ago 01:24:11 1
Ask Me Anything - Douglas Murray, Sam Harris, Jordan Peterson, Matt Dillahunty, Richard Dawkins
6 months ago 00:20:58 1
NIGHTWISH - The Greatest Show on Earth (with Richard Dawkins) (OFFICIAL LIVE)
7 months ago 01:22:09 1
(New 2023 Dialogues) Richard Dawkins & Lawrence Krauss Interview | 2 Conversation Combo Episode
7 months ago 00:23:40 1
Ричард Докинз “Эгоистичный ген“ - глава вторая “РЕПЛИКАТОРЫ“
7 months ago 01:08:53 1
Can We Live Without Religion? - Alex O’Connor
7 months ago 00:04:13 1
The Rolling Stones - Monkey Man (Official Lyric Video)